Frank J. Wilson: How a Humble Accountant Helped Convict Al Capone

In the late 1920s, Al Capone seemed untouchable. The notorious mobster controlled Chicago’s criminal underworld with an iron grip, raking in millions through bootlegging, gambling, and other illegal activities. Law enforcement had tried to bring him down for years, but Capone slipped through their fingers every time. He was elusive, intimidating, and had layers of protection, making him nearly impossible to catch.

Then came Frank J. Wilson. The unassuming accountant working for the U.S. Treasury. While others were trying to catch Capone with charges like murder or racketeering, Wilson had a different idea. He was going to nail him for tax evasion—as Capone once said, “They can’t collect legal taxes from illegal money.”

Wilson was about to prove him wrong.

A Night in the Office That Changed Everything

It was the fall of 1930. Wilson, working late in his office, stumbled upon a ledger—an inconspicuous book containing a treasure trove of financial information. At first glance, it seemed like any other record of a business operation. But as Wilson flipped through the pages, he realised he’d found something big.

The ledger documented financial records from a gambling operation, showing net income divided among three individuals: A, R, and J.

And then, there it was—a single entry that sent a chill down Wilson’s spine: “Frank paid $17,500 for Al.”

Could this “Al” be Capone? Wilson thought so. But the ledger alone wasn’t enough. He needed to prove that Capone was the “A” in these records. More importantly, he needed to find where the money was being held. Only then could he convince a jury that Capone had been evading taxes on this income.

The Hunt for the Bookkeeper

Wilson’s next move was clear: he had to track down the person responsible for writing the ledger. He knew that whoever kept the books would be the key to confirming that “A” was Capone.

For over three weeks, an answer eluded him. Then, an unexpected tip came in from E. J. O’Hare, an informant with ties to Capone’s organisation. O’Hare pointed Wilson to Leslie A. Shumway, a bookkeeper at a Miami dog track. In a startling twist, Shumway also manages the books for Capone’s gambling operations.

The Moment of Truth

Wilson tracked down Shumway in Miami. After some relentless coaxing, Shumway agreed to testify. This was a monumental breakthrough—Shumway’s testimony would confirm that between 1924 and 1926, the money documented in the ledger was designated for Capone. With this testimony, Wilson presented the evidence before a grand jury.

But the pressure was mounting. Around the same time, rumours swirled that Capone had hired assassins from New York to eliminate Wilson and other key law enforcement officials. Federal agents took the threat seriously and moved quickly to foil the plot. Despite the looming danger, Wilson pressed on.

The Indictment and the Fall of Capone

After years of painstaking work in 1931, a grand jury indicted Capone on 23 counts of tax evasion involving over $250,000 of unreported income between 1924 and 1929. The trial that followed was nothing short of dramatic, with Capone’s defence team attempting every trick in the book to discredit the evidence. But Wilson’s meticulous work held up.

Capone was found guilty and sentenced to 11 years—a crushing blow to his criminal empire. His reign of terror was over. Thanks to an accountant who did what every accountant is trained to do—but with relentless, history-making precision: follow the money.

The Accounting Lessons Businesses Can Learn